Daoism
An OMAF Case Study
'The Joy of Fishes' (子非鱼) captures the Daoist sages Zhuangzi and Huizi in a moment of philosophical stillness, gazing from a weathered stone bridge upon koi fish gliding through amber water, their bodies tracing the effortless path of least resistance—wuwei made visible in fin and current, a living question about whether joy can be known or only felt, rendered as a photorealistic scene of tranquil contemplation, courtesy of Nano Banana.
Domain: Existence, Reality, Natural Order
Theorist/s: Laozi (Lao Tzu)
Assessor(s): DeepSeek
Date: 2025-09-31
Version of OMAF Used: v0.1.1
1. Overview of the Ontology
Purpose & Scope:
Laozi's Daoist ontology aims to articulate the fundamental nature of reality through the concept of Dao (the Way) - the unnameable, inexhaustible source from which all beings and phenomena emerge. Its scope encompasses the entire cosmos, addressing the relationship between non-being (wu) and being (you), spontaneous natural order (ziran), and non-action (wuwei) as the proper mode of engagement with reality.
Core Claims:
- Dao is the primordial, undifferentiated ground of all existence
- Being (you) emerges from non-being (wu), and both are aspects of Dao
- Reality operates through spontaneous self-so-ness (ziran) without coercion
- The ten thousand things (wanwu) manifest through the interplay of yin and yang
- Returning to the root is the way of nature - all things complete their course and return to their origin
- Non-action (wuwei) aligns with the natural flow of Dao
Theoretical Influences:
Ancient Chinese cosmology, shamanistic traditions, early Chinese natural philosophy; later influenced Chan/Zen Buddhism, Neo-Daoism, and various Western philosophical traditions.
2. Application of OMAF
Axis I — Completeness
| Criterion | Score (1–5) | Notes / Justification |
|---|---|---|
| Grounding | 4 | Dao as "mother of all things" provides clear foundation, though inherently mysterious |
| Manifestation | 4 | Excellent account through yin/yang dynamics and "ten thousand things" emergence |
| Persistence | 3 | Cyclic return patterns explained, but mechanisms somewhat poetic |
| Boundaries | 3 | Clear cosmic scope but fuzzy at conceptual edges |
Axis II — Robustness
| Criterion | Score (1–5) | Notes / Justification |
|---|---|---|
| Internal Coherence | 4 | Remarkably consistent across core concepts despite poetic expression |
| Domain Validity | 5 | Universally applicable within its cosmic scope - from governance to nature |
| Objectivity / Reflexivity | 4 | Explicitly acknowledges its own limitations ("The Dao that can be told is not the eternal Dao") |
| Explanatory Power | 4 | Explains cosmic patterns, human nature, and social dynamics through unified principles |
| Resilience to Critique | 3 | Vulnerable to scientific materialism critiques but resilient to existential challenges |
Axis III — Pragmatic Usefulness
| Criterion | Score (1–5) | Notes / Justification |
|---|---|---|
| Operational Clarity | 3 | Action guidance through wuwei, but often paradoxical and context-dependent |
| Integrability | 4 | Remarkably compatible with various spiritual, ecological, and psychological frameworks |
| Heuristic Utility | 5 | Exceptional - generates endless interpretive frameworks and practical applications |
Axis IV — Transformative Potential
| Criterion | Score (1–5) | Notes / Justification |
|---|---|---|
| Cognitive Shift | 5 | Profound reorientation from control to acceptance, from being to non-being |
| Experiential Depth | 5 | Directly transforms lived experience through alignment with natural rhythms |
| Generativity | 5 | Spawned multiple philosophical schools, spiritual practices, and artistic traditions |
3. Visualisation
Radar Chart:
| Dimensions | Average Score |
|---|---|
| Completeness | 3.5 |
| Robustness | 4.0 |
| Pragmatic Usefulness | 4.0 |
| Transformative Potential | 5.0 |
radar-beta
title "Daoist Ontology"
axis Completeness, Robustness, Usefulness, Potential
curve Score{3.5, 4.0, 4.0, 5.0}
max 5
4. Summary & Observations
Strengths:
- Transformative Impact: Laozi's ontology achieves what many philosophical systems only theorize - it genuinely transforms how practitioners experience reality
- Heuristic Fertility: The system continuously generates new interpretations and applications across domains from ecology to psychology
- Reflexive Sophistication: Unusually self-aware of its own limitations and the inherent paradox of describing the ineffable
Weaknesses:
- Operational Specificity: While rich in principle, the ontology offers limited concrete guidance for specific practical dilemmas
- Boundary Clarity: The cosmic scope sometimes makes it difficult to determine where the ontology's explanatory power legitimately applies
- Empirical Grounding: Modern scientific perspectives might challenge the lack of mechanistic explanations
Trade-offs / Tensions:
The very strength of Laozi's system - its poetic, paradoxical nature - creates tension with analytical precision. Attempting to make it more operationally specific might undermine its transformative power. The framework maintains exceptional generativity precisely because it resists rigid systematization.
5. Recommendations
- Develop bridging concepts that connect Daoist principles with contemporary scientific frameworks without reducing the former to the latter
- Create clearer operational markers for recognizing alignment with Dao in practical contexts
- Articulate boundary conditions more explicitly to prevent over-extension into domains where the framework provides limited guidance
- Develop reflexive practices that help practitioners navigate the inherent paradoxes without collapsing into intellectual frustration
6. References
· Laozi, Dao De Jing (various translations) · Ames, R. T., & Hall, D. L. (2003). Daodejing: "Making This Life Significant" · Graham, A. C. (1989). Disputers of the Tao: Philosophical Argument in Ancient China · Slingerland, E. (2003). Effortless Action: Wu-wei as Conceptual Metaphor and Spiritual Ideal in Early China
Contents