Pratityasamutpada and the conference of difference
Understanding dependent arising and the process that realizes it
In brief
The Buddha's teaching of dependent arising (pratityasamutpada; Pali: paṭiccasamuppāda) is the claim that whatever exists is conditional. Nothing exists in isolation; everything that is, is in dependence on conditions.
The article sets this principle beside an independent process ontology, the conference of difference (CoD). The CoD was not derived from dependent arising; it was derived separately, from observation of how existents bear together and apart. What the comparison shows is a convergence: two independent inquiries arriving at the same structure. Dependent arising observes the conditionality of existence; the CoD observes and relates the process of that conditionality.
One distinction is essential and runs through the whole article. The Vedic cosmogonies and the twelve-link chain are linear: cause gives rise to effect, effect becomes cause of the next effect, a sequence of stages. The CoD is mutual: cause and effect are not two stages but one process, each side of which is both cause and effect of the other. The conference of difference is the process primitive, and cause and effect are its two faces, not its two stages. The CoD converges with dependent arising at the level of the principle (everything is conditioned; nothing exists in isolation), but it departs from the chain-form at the level of the structure. This article shows both the convergence and the departure.
1. The observation both begin from
We can begin with something neither tradition disputes:
No thing exists in isolation.
A particle is what it is in relation to other particles. A cell is what it is in relation to its environment. A thought is what it is in relation to other thoughts, and to the mind that holds them. A self is what it is in relation to other selves, and to the conditions that formed it. There is no entity anywhere that is what it is independently of anything else. Everything is constituted by its relations and distinctions.
This is not a metaphysical theory. It is an observation available to anyone who looks. And it is the observation from which both dependent arising and the CoD begin.
The Buddha's formulation is the most economical statement of it in the history of philosophy:
When this is, that is; from the arising of this comes the arising of that. When this is not, that is not; from the cessation of this comes the cessation of that. (Ud 1.1–3; SN 12.61)
Nothing arises alone. Everything that is, is in dependence on conditions. That is dependent arising.
The CoD's formulation is a restatement of the same observation in process terms:
Existence is a conference of difference, a 'condition of bearing together' that transforms the 'condition of bearing apart'. (Kn 10.1)
Nothing exists alone. Rather everything exists as a condition: 'process of declaring together'. That is the conference of difference.
1.1 The lexical proof
The Pali samutpāda is a compound: sam (together) + ud (out, up) + √pad (to go, to step, to walk). The literal morphology is stepping out together: what exists steps out of the convergence of conditions. The 'together' is the dependency: the convergence that the stepping-out depends on. The 'stepping out' is the action of arising itself. So the morphology states the principle of dependent arising: the together is the condition, the stepping out is the action.
The Pali dhamma: 'thing', stems from √dhar: to 'bear' and by extension, dhamma: 'that which bears'. The CoD's vocabulary is built on a similar root sense, albeit from Latin ferō: to 'bear' as in confer: 'bear together', and differ: 'bear apart'. Thus the Buddhist dhamma: 'that which bears' is implicitly conditional, because a bearing is always a bearing of something, and the CoD's conference of difference is conditional in the same way: a bearing-together is always a bearing-together of differences.
The CoD's definition of condition: 'process of declaring together' and the Buddhist samutpāda: 'stepping out together' are the same verbal structure, a gathering that issues. The CoD's 'bearing together' and the Buddhist 'stepping out together' share the same 'together', the same dependency, the same condition. That is not a coincidence of translation. It is the structure of the word matching the structure of the insight, twice over: once at the level of process (both are verbal nouns), and once at the level of what a thing is (both are bearings).
2. What dependent arising states
Dependent arising is the Buddha's central teaching. The canonical identification is explicit: 'One who sees dependent arising sees the Dhamma, and one who sees the Dhamma sees dependent arising' (MN 28). It is not one teaching among many; it is the teaching.
What does it state? Three things.
First: everything conditioned arises in dependence on conditions. No thing is uncaused. No thing is self-caused. No thing stands outside the network of conditioning. This is the universal scope of the principle, stated in the texts as holding 'whether Tathāgatas arise or not' (SN 12.20), which is to say: it is not a teaching the Buddha invented, but a feature of reality the Buddha discovered.
Second: the conditions are specific. It is not that any thing can produce any thing. This condition gives rise to this phenomenon. The Pali term is idappaccayatā: 'specific conditionality'. The relation is determinate: given specific conditions, a specific condition of being arises; given the cessation of specific conditions, the specific condition of being ceases.
Third: the principle is invariant. The conditional relation does not fluctuate. It is dhammaṭṭhitatā: 'the stableness of the Dhamma', dhammaniyāmatā: 'the fixed course of the Dhamma'. The phenomena that arise are impermanent; the principle by which they arise is not.[1]
These three, universality, specificity and invariance, are what dependent arising states. They are the structure of existence.
3. The dispute about scope
The question is what the twelve-link chain describes. Two readings are available.
The psychological reading. The chain describes the process by which a sentient being produces suffering. Every link is mental or experiential: ignorance, formations, consciousness, name-and-form, sense bases, contact, feeling, craving, clinging, becoming, birth, aging-death. The doctrine is introduced in soteriological contexts, not cosmological ones. On this reading, dependent arising is an analysis of the mind, and its purpose is to show where suffering comes from and how it can cease.
The universal reading. The chain is one application of a broader principle. The principle is that all existence arises in dependence on conditions. The twelve links are the specific application of that principle to the case of suffering. On this reading, dependent arising is an analysis of conditioned existence—ontology, and the twelve links are the specific soteriological instance of it serving the Buddhist project of liberation.
4. The principle and the instances: SN 12.20
The decisive text is the Paccaya Sutta (SN 12.20). It distinguishes two things that the later tradition sometimes conflates:
- Paṭiccasamuppāda: 'having depended on [conditions], stepping out together' i.e. the principle of dependent arising.
- Paṭiccasamuppannā dhammā: 'things that, having depended on [conditions], have stepped out together' i.e. the specific instances themselves which in this sutta is the twelve links.
The distinction is stated with a formula that carries the universality claim:
uppādā vā tathāgatānaṃ anuppādā vā tathāgatānaṃ, ṭhitāva sā dhātu dhammaṭṭhitatā dhammaniyāmatā idappaccayatā.
'Whether Tathāgatas arise or not, that element still persists, the stableness of the Dhamma, the fixed course of the Dhamma, specific conditionality.'
The universality is in the 'whether Tathāgatas arise or not' clause. The conditional relation is not created by the Buddha. It holds before him, after him, and independently of him. He discovers it; he does not invent it.
The commentary unpacks three technical terms:
| Term | Commentary's gloss | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| dhammaṭṭhitatā (stableness) | 'That element, the intrinsic nature of the conditions, still persists; never is it the case that birth is not a condition for aging-and-death' | The conditional relation is invariant, it does not fluctuate |
| dhammaniyāmatā (fixed course) | 'The condition fixes/determines the dependent phenomena; therefore it is called the fixed course of the Dhamma' | The relation is deterministic, the condition necessitates the conditioned |
| idappaccayatā (specific conditionality) | 'The set of specific conditions for aging-and-death, etc.' | The relation is specific, not just any condition, but this condition for this phenomenon |
The universality here is ontological, though implicit: the law is said to hold whether or not a Buddha exists, which is to say it is independent of any knower, a feature of reality rather than a construction of the mind. The modal language reinforces this: the law is invariable and fixed, dhammaṭṭhitatā, dhammaniyāmatā. The text asserts the law's invariance, and invariance is universality: a law that holds without exception, independently of any knower, is a law that expresses itself constantly. That is the constant expression — the principle as dhammaṭṭhitatā, stable and fixed. What the text does not explicitly state is the scope of the law — that it covers all phenomena, at every scale. But the universality of the law is already there in the invariance claim. The scope is an inference from the universality, not a separate claim.
The parallel that clarifies the structure is AN 3.136, where the same 'whether Tathāgatas arise or not' formula is applied to the Three Characteristics:
'Whether Tathāgatas arise or not, there persists that law, that stableness of the Dhamma, that fixed course of the Dhamma: 'All conditioned phenomena are impermanent.''
This shows the formula is a rhetorical template: 'this law is invariant and not created by the Buddha.' The content of the law varies. In SN 12.20 the content is the conditional relation; in AN 3.136 the content is the three marks. The universality is the invariance of the law, not yet the scope of phenomena to which it applies.
The inference is licensed by the text's own language. If the conditional relation is invariant, i.e. holds whether or not a Buddha exists, then the principle it expresses is not a psychological observation but an ontological declaration of reality. The twelve links are the instance the Buddha worked out first, because that is the instance that matters for liberation (the Buddhist project). The principle is broader than the instance, and the text's own universality formula says so.
5. The constant expression: what the Buddhist principle and the CoD share
The structure of the relation between principle and instance is the same in the early texts and in the CoD. The principle of conditionality is invariable and stable; the phenomena it governs are variable and impermanent. The principle is the constant; the extant variables subject to the principle realize (arise) via probability resulting from specific conditions.
That is exactly the structure the CoD proposes. The conference of difference is the constant expression where things: 'assemblies' represent some stabilization of expression: the "process of pressing out'. Same structure, different vocabulary:
| Paṭiccasamuppāda | CoD | |
|---|---|---|
| The constant | Idappaccayatā, the invariant conditional principle | The conference of difference, the process primitive |
| The expression | Paṭiccasamuppannā dhammā, the variable, impermanent phenomena | The specific phenomena that press out of the conference |
| The dynamic | Samutpāda, stepping out, together, from conditions | Pressing out, the phenomenon issuing from bearing together |
| The status | 'Whether Tathāgatas arise or not, this element persists' | The CoD holds whether or not anyone is aware of it |
| The relation to the whole | 'Germinative source for the vast network of doctrines' | The process primitive from which all existence is generated |
The one thing the Buddhist texts do not say, and the CoD does say explicitly, is that the constant principle is itself a process. The texts call it dhammaṭṭhitatā, a stableness. The CoD says the constant is not a fixed law but an ongoing conference of difference, always pressing out, never a completed state. That is the genuine extension at the level of the principle, and it is the one that makes the ontology genuinely process rather than merely relational.
6. Where the CoD departs: mutual, not linear
Everything up to this point has been about convergence at the level of the principle. This section is the departure at the level of the structure, and it is the one that distinguishes the CoD from both the twelve-link chain and Vedic cosmogonies.
The twelve-link chain is linear. Ignorance conditions formations; formations condition consciousness; consciousness conditions name-and-form; and so on. Each link is the cause of the next, and the next is the effect of the previous. The chain is a sequence of stages, and the direction of conditioning runs from one stage to the next. The same is true of the Vedic cosmogony: a primal state gives rise to a creative act, which gives rise to the world, in a sequence.
However, in terms of the CoD, there is no linear chain of events, no sequence. There is only the continuing strengthening or weakening of interdependent conferences, each shaping the continuum from impossibility through possibility to actuality: what cannot be borne together, what could be, and what is.
%%{init: {"flowchart": {"htmlLabels": true, "nodeSpacing": 40, "rankSpacing": 48, "padding": 16}}}%%
flowchart TD
A("<b>0 — Impossibility</b><br/><i>that which is able to maybe—not</i><br/>Conditions necessary for realizing are absent")
B("<b>1 — Possibility</b><br/><i>that which is able to maybe</i><br/>Conditions necessary for realizing are present")
C("<b>2 — Probability</b><br/><i>that which is able to prove</i><br/>Conditions necessary for realizing are proving")
D("<b>3 — Actuality</b><br/><i>that which has acted</i><br/>Conditions necessary for realizing are actualized")
A --> B --> C --> D
classDef stage0 fill:#F5F7FA,stroke:#4B5868,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray:5 4,color:#1A2533
classDef stage1 fill:#E2EEFB,stroke:#277EE8,stroke-width:1px,color:#1A2533
classDef stage2 fill:#CDE1F9,stroke:#277EE8,stroke-width:1.5px,color:#1A2533
classDef stage3 fill:#277EE8,stroke:#135AB0,stroke-width:1.5px,color:#FFFFFF
class A stage0
class B stage1
class C stage2
class D stage3
linkStyle default stroke:#277EE8,stroke-width:1.5px
Figure 1: From impossibility to actuality—a continuum.
The distinction is easiest to see in a case that is not an analogy but an instance. A conversation is a conference of difference. The participants are who they are partly in virtue of the conversation, and the conversation is what it is partly in virtue of the participants. Neither comes first. There is no conversation without participants, and no participants, in the relevant sense, without the conversation they are having. The conversation strengthens or weakens as the participants engage or withdraw: where one falls silent, the conversation weakens and what can be said next moves back along the continuum toward impossibility; where both engage, it strengthens and what can be said next moves toward actuality. What is possible in a conversation is not fixed in advance; it is negotiated in the conferring. That is the structure of the CoD: not a chain of stages, but a mutual bearing in which each side changes the other, and in which what is possible and what is actual is continually renegotiated.
The same process appears at every scale. A particle is a conference of difference of field and excitation. A solar system is a conference of difference of mass and motion. A thought is a conference of difference of chemical signals and electrical impulses across a neural network. In each case, neither side comes first. Each changes the other, and the changing is the conference: what can be borne together strengthens or weakens, and what is possible and what is actual shifts along the continuum.
This is where the CoD departs from the chain-form, and the departure is not a rejection of dependent arising but a strengthening of it. The principle says everything is conditioned; the CoD says the conditioning is a conference of difference, and in the CoD each side changes the other. The cause-effect chain is one way of modelling the Buddhist principle, and it is a useful way for its soteriological case, because it functions as an easy way for humans to grasp the Buddhist model of human suffering. The CoD is another way of modelling the same principle, and it is the more precise way, because it emphasises the mutuality of dependent arising. It claims that the principle the texts state is a more complex interrelationship than the simple linear form in which they state it.
We sequence the world to grasp it, and then we reify the sequence into time. The chain is what the world looks like once it has been sequenced: a way of sampling, not a structure we observe. The reification of time is what makes the chain look like the world rather than a model of the world. So the CoD's departure from the linear causal chain is not just a different model; it is a refusal to reify the temporal model of linear cause and effect. The complex inter-relational reading, in which multiple conferences of difference interrelate along continua of possibility, is the one that captures the principle at its full scope.
7. What this means for the CoD: convergence, not derivation
Everything up to this point is exegetical. This section is the constructive claim.
The early Buddhist principle of conditionality (idappaccayatā) is stated as universal in the texts, "whether Tathāgatas arise or not, this element persists", but applied only to the psychological case and modelled only in a linear form.
The CoD was not derived from this. It was derived independently, from observation of how existents bear together and apart, without consulting the Buddhist texts. What the comparison shows is a convergence: two independent inquiries, arriving at the same structure. The CoD reads the conditioning as mutual rather than sequential, and it applies to all conditioned processes, not only to the case of suffering. That is what the early texts implied but never explicitly did.
The convergence is the interesting fact, not the derivation. If the CoD had been built from dependent arising, the agreement would be circular. Because it was built independently, the agreement is evidence that both are describing the same structure, from different starting points, in different vocabularies.
The Vedic material sharpens this. The conditional-chain form was available in the intellectual milieu before the Buddha, and the form is universal, which means the CoD's use of it is a convergence on a universal form rather than a borrowing from Buddhism specifically. But the form is universal because it is the form of process itself, not because there is a single underlying doctrine that all three traditions share. The convergence is at the level of the form; the doctrines are different.
The texts do not say that conditionality applies to all phenomena without exception; they state the principle as universal and apply it to the case of suffering. The texts do not say that the conditioning is mutual; they model it as linear. The CoD does not claim they said more than they did. It claims that the principle they stated is broader than the application they carried out, and broader than the linear form in which they carried it out. The broader principle, mutual and universal, is the one worth developing.
Glossary
- Dhammaṭṭhitatā: the stableness or invariance of the Dhamma; the principle's not fluctuating.
- Idappaccayatā: specific conditionality; the principle that specific conditions give rise to specific phenomena.
- Paṭiccasamuppāda: dependent origination; the principle of conditionality.
- Paṭiccasamuppannā dhammā: dependently arisen phenomena; the instances of the principle.
- Samutpāda: the second element of the compound; literally 'stepping out together,' pressing out.
- CoD (conference of difference): the view that to exist is to be an ongoing process in which differences are held together and pressed out as phenomena.
Sources
- SN 12.20 (Paccaya Sutta), SN 12.61, AN 3.136, MN 28
- Ṛg Veda 10.129 (Nāsadīya-sūkta); Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 1.4; Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa 2.2.4, 6.2.1
- Bhikkhu Bodhi, introduction to the Upanisa Sutta (Wheel 277)
- Richard Gombrich, What the Buddha Thought (Equinox, 2009)
- Joanna Jurewicz, 'Playing with Fire: The Pratītyasamutpāda from the Perspective of Vedic Thought,' Journal of the Pali Text Society 26 (2000): 77–103
- Evgeny Shulman, 'Early Meanings of Dependent-Origination,' Journal of Indian Philosophy 36, no. 2 (2008): 297–317
- Alex Wayman, 'Buddhist Dependent Origination,' History of Religions 10, no. 3 (1971): 185–203
- Tsongkhapa, In Praise of Dependent Origination
Footnotes
This matches the CoD claim that the CoD process itself (the conference of difference) is determinate but the extent variables participating in that process realize via probability. ↩︎